The Absence of a Defensive Architect
Makar’s injury has exposed critical gaps in the Avalanche’s game plan, particularly in transitioning the puck and supporting their top line. In Game 1, the team’s inability to exit their zone cleanly and maintain possession led to the game-winning goal, a sequence that underscored Makar’s role as a playmaker. “He’s an important player, right?” defenseman Josh Manson said, noting the “trickle-down effect” on both defensemen and forwards. “Some of the areas that we struggled with tonight, those are his strengths.” [2]
The Avalanche’s 8-1 postseason record with Makar in the lineup contrasts sharply with their 0-1 mark without him. His absence forced coach Jared Bednar to rely on veterans like Devon Toews (27:32 in Game 1) and Brett Kulak, while rookie Jack Ahcan, who played just 7:34, was inserted as a stopgap. “You’re going to lose guys during a playoff run and he’s a big part of it,” goalie Scott Wedgewood said. “But it’s next-man-up mentality.” [2]
A Fractured Game Plan
The Avalanche’s struggles were most evident in their power-play execution. Sam Malinski, filling in for Makar, took a shot that was blocked, leading to a 2-on-1 transition that resulted in the Golden Knights’ third goal. “It (stinks), just that play,” Malinski admitted. “Losing by one goal, that’s kind of the difference.” [2]
Makar’s absence also disrupted the chemistry of Nathan MacKinnon’s line, which typically plays alongside the star defenseman. “The puck-moving — he likes to break the puck out himself a lot of times,” forward Nazem Kadri said. “As forwards, I know that I can just find some space and I’m going to get the puck.” [3]
Medical Uncertainty and Playoff Implications
While Makar skated during the Avalanche’s morning practice on May 22, coach Bednar confirmed he would not play in Game 2, leaving the team’s playoff hopes hanging in the balance. The injury, described as an “upper-body” issue, has raised concerns about his availability for Game 3 in Las Vegas. “I don’t think when you’re playing you can think about it,” Manson added, emphasizing the mental toll of his absence. “I think that’s just a hindrance. Going into it, obviously you hope he’s playing.” [1]
The Golden Knights, aware of Makar’s impact, have maintained their focus on their own game plan. “Obviously a great player,” Vegas defenseman Brayden McNabb said. “Probably the best defenseman in the League. But it doesn’t change anything as of now, right?” [1]
A Test of Resilience
The Avalanche’s next-man-up approach has drawn praise, but the team’s depth remains unproven at this stage of the playoffs. With Makar’s future uncertain, the pressure falls on veterans like Toews and Kulak to replicate his leadership and puck-moving precision. “I was proud of the d-corps in front of me,” Wedgewood said, acknowledging the challenges of stepping into Makar’s role. “It wasn’t much. Just a couple there I’d like to have back.” [2]
As the series shifts to Las Vegas, the Avalanche must address their defensive breakdowns and find ways to compensate for the loss of their defensive anchor. For now, the team’s fate hinges on whether Makar can return in time to salvage their Stanley Cup aspirations. “You have to concentrate on what you need to do in the moment,” Bednar said, echoing the mindset required to navigate this critical juncture. [1]
The Broader Stakes
Makar’s injury adds to the Avalanche’s challenges in a tightly contested Western Conference final. The team’s success in 2022 hinged on his dominance, and his absence risks repeating the playoff struggles that plagued them in previous seasons. With the Golden Knights poised to capitalize, the Avalanche’s ability to adapt will determine whether they can overcome this setback.
For fans, the uncertainty surrounding Makar’s return underscores the fragility of championship runs. “I think that’s just a hindrance,” Manson said, summing up the collective frustration. “When you’re out there, I don’t think you want to think about it. I think you just got to keep playing and doing your best to win the game.” As the team prepares for tonight's critical matchup, the focus remains entirely on securing a victory while navigating the difficult challenge of playing without their star defenseman in the lineup.
